Campaign

Graham Platner’s political outsider vibe gains steam in Maine among Democrats

Comments:

by Amie Parnes - 04/03/26 6:00 AM ET

Comments:

Link copied

by Amie Parnes - 04/03/26 6:00 AM ET

Comments:

Link copied

NOW PLAYING

Graham Platner, an oyster farmer with a plainspoken style, isn’t a typical Senate candidate. But in a cycle where political outsiders are increasingly gaining traction, candidates like him are no longer outliers — they’re becoming contenders.

Platner’s candidacy is an early test of that shift. In Maine, where Sen. Susan Collins (R) has long defied political gravity, some early polling suggests he could mount a credible challenge — and outperform more traditional candidates like Maine Gov. Janet Mills (D) in the process.

Mills, who is 78 and a familiar face to Mainers, has put out a string of negative ads against the 41-year-old Platner, including highlighting insensitive comments he made about rape. To date, it hasn’t moved the needle in polls.

An Emerson College poll released in late March, for example, showed Platner ahead of Mills by about 27 points, with Platner receiving support from 55 percent of those surveyed, while Mills received 28 percent. The poll said 17 percent of those polled were undecided.

“I think it’s not as much an anti-Mills phenomenon as a pro-Platner one,” Democratic strategist Christy Setzer said. “Fairly or not, Mills represents the current Democratic Party to voters — too old, too weak to fight [President] Trump, [which] may be unfair, but the rep nonetheless, not understanding where the base is.

“Platner, meanwhile, reads as ‘outsider,’ younger, anti-establishment at a time when even the Democrats kind of hate the Democrats.”

Platner isn’t the only outsider candidate benefitting from the trend.

In the last year alone, 34-year-old Zohran Mamdani was elected mayor of New York City, defeating former New York Gov. Andrew Cuomo (D) in the process, while state Rep. James Talarico defeated Rep. Jasmine Crockett to become the Democratic Senate nominee in Texas.

Both Democrats, like Platner, operated outside the traditional party structure and found new openings with voters thirsty for change.

The shift reflects a broader frustration with political institutions, as well as a changing landscape in which candidates can build their own campaigns without relying on the party or traditional means of fundraising for support.

“We’re in a highly volatile and polarized cycle where many voters are seeking new narratives,” said former Rep. Steve Israel (D-N.Y.), who chaired the Democratic Congressional Campaign Committee. “When things seem so drastically different, voters become more interested in candidates who are similarly different.”

Democratic strategist Joel Payne agreed, adding that “because trust in the institutions remain low, credible outside voices are at a premium right now.”

“The further distance you have from the politics of the recent past, the better in terms of building popular support,” he said.

Not everyone has to be outside the power structure to win outsider support.

Payne said politicians including Sens. Bernie Sanders (I-Vt.) and Ruben Gallego (D-Ariz.) and Rep. Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez (D-N.Y.) have been able to “hold trust from within the institutions.”

“But those folks have been able to demonstrate to the public and to their base of supporters that they are reform minded,” he said.

The Maine race is key if Democrats are to have any hope of reclaiming the Senate majority.

Some wonder if Platner is the right candidate given his history of incendiary remarks. In the fall, Platner also had to explain a tattoo that resembled a Nazi skull and crossbones and promised to have it removed after it caused a stir.

In recent weeks, Mills has sought to remind voters about Platner’s past comments on rape, which he posted on Reddit more than 10 years ago. She’s done so with a flood of advertising featuring women who read the posts.

In one such missive, Platner says women worried about rape should “not get so f‑‑‑ed up they wind up having sex with someone they don’t mean to.”

“That’s disgusting!” a woman in one ad says.

James Melcher, a professor of political science at the University of Maine at Farmington, said that for Mainers, it comes down to one question: “Is experience a good thing or is experience a liability?”

“It’s an asset for Graham Platner that he’s different,” Melcher said. “His supporters are very forgiving of the things he has said in the past.”

“There are people here who wouldn’t mind some turnover,” he said, highlighting that the fact that Mills is tied to Senate Minority Leader Chuck Schumer (D-N.Y) is “not helpful.”

At the same time, Melcher added, the race is “not a done deal.”

If Platner does win the primary, he’ll then have to contend with Collins, who has repeatedly turned aside Democratic challengers.

During Collins’s last campaign against Democrat Sara Gideon — a very traditional, well-funded candidate