Sarah Michelle Gellar Andy Cohen Feud Explained

by Larry FitzmauriceBuzzFeedBuzzFeed StaffI'm a writer and editor who lives in Brooklyn, New York, and I've written for a variety of publications across the last 20 years, including The New York Times, The Guardian, GQ, New York Magazine, Pitchfork, The Fader—the list goes on.

Sarah Michelle Gellar and Andy Cohen may seem happy in this picture — but in the weeks since it was taken, things have taken a real turn.

Gary Gershoff / Getty Images

NEW YORK, NEW YORK - MARCH 18: Sarah Michelle Gellar the Radio Andy show with hosts Andy Cohen (L) and John Hill at SiriusXM Studios on March 18, 2026 in New York City. (Photo by Gary Gershoff/Getty Images)

Here's the deal: During a recent appearance on Page Six Radio, the Ready Or Not 2 star got real about her feelings regarding the latest season of Real Housewives of Beverly Hills. Even though she said she's "obsessed" with the show as a whole, Sarah admitted that she thinks the currently-airing Season 15 is "boring."

Page Six Radio

“I mean, I like the cast," Sarah went on. "I want a Jen Tilly, Kathy Hilton spinoff. But it’s slow. It’s just picking up now.”

Gary Gershoff / Getty Images

Then, Sarah went in on RHOBH's latest cast addition, Amanda Frances — and she did not mince words. “I don’t think she’s polarizing, I just don’t think anyone enjoys her," Sarah said, before choosing to "clarify" that "I’m sure she’s a very lovely person."

Bravo / Charles Sykes/Bravo via Getty Images

"If you choose to go on this show, then you have to be ready to open yourself up and be honest. And I don’t know, I feel like she just missed that memo…Like, have you ever watched an episode?”

Page Six Radio

Now, if you know one thing about the don dadda of Bravo himself, it's that Andy is not one to take such criticisms lying down — and during a recent episode of his Radio Andy show, he responded to SMG's opinions.

Noam Galai / Getty Images

Now, here's the twist: Andy's real issue with the entire situation is that Page Six Radio shoots in the same recording studio as Radio Andy — so, if you take a look at the pic below, you can see hints of the Radio Andy decorations behind SMG as she appears on Page Six Radio.

Page Six Radio

“Page Six Radio interviewed Sarah Michelle Gellar," Andy said, before noting how the two shows share the same space. “And then they post it. And it’s like, ‘Sarah Michelle Gellar hates the Housewives of Beverly Hills’ with all of this Radio Andy signage everywhere."

Bravo / Charles Sykes/Bravo via Getty Images

“And I was like, ‘You know what? Don’t bring someone into my studio to trash my show.’ How about, the door is locked when I leave? How’s that? Or maybe think twice about posting that all over social media, where it says ‘Andy’ everywhere behind SMG."

Travis P. Ball / SXSW Conference & Festivals via Getty Images

Of course, Andy took issue with SMG's Housewives take as well: "She wrong, by the way," he asserted.

Raymond Hall / GC Images

Yikes! Well then...what do you think about all of this? Let us know in the comments.

Comments