Critic's Notebook: Taylor Frankie Paul and an Out-of-Step Franchise
Taylor Frankie Paul
Fred Hayes/Disney via Getty Images
-
Share on Facebook
-
Share on X
-
Google Preferred
-
Share to Flipboard
-
Show additional share options
-
Share on LinkedIn
-
Share on Pinterest
-
Share on Reddit
-
Share on Tumblr
-
Share on Whats App
-
Send an Email
-
Print the Article
-
Post a Comment
At its best, reality TV thrives as one of the few television formats that allow genuine insight into the fleshy underbelly of human behavior — albeit edited and manipulated to a producer’s satisfaction. While a genre largely driven by drunken foibles could be dismissed as juvenile, this model of programming offers a level of accessibility to major quotidian life events such as childbirth, marriage, divorce, infidelity and financial instability — inevitabilities for the average TV watcher, no matter your gender, race or class — here processed through the lens of a young dilettante searching for fame.
No themes are more universal than love and success, whether it’s striving for and preserving them or feeling a chance at happiness slip between your fingers before looking for the next lucky break. Enter the gamified reality dating show, where The Bachelor and its spinoffs have been an industry leader.
Related Stories
TV
Taylor Frankie Paul 'Bachelorette' Contestant Involved in Madison Cawthorn Crash Says God Has "Already Forgiven" Her
TV
It's Time to End the 'Bachelor' Franchise
Part of what makes this phenomenon so fascinating is how deeply the franchise’s DNA is tied to a very specific vision of the American dream — and for years, that vision went largely unchallenged, even as it quietly reinforced the idea that desirability itself had a default setting. From its earliest iterations, The Bachelor sold a highly curated vision of the picket-fence romance in all its heteronormative glory (after all, it wasn’t until season 13 of The Bachelorette that the show cast its first Black female lead, Rachel Lindsay, yielding a set of episodes that were equal parts historic and revealing).
The franchise’s format can be traced all the way back to The Dating Game, not just in its structure, but in its broader willingness to suspend disbelief around romance itself: The fantasy was the point. It wasn’t supposed to feel real so much as inspirational, with all the flair and spectacle that adorn fairy tale romances — helicopter ride, cliffside proposal with blinding diamond (string quartet in tow), etc.
Increasingly, however, the show’s conceit feels like it belongs to a different media epoch, as present-day audiences seem to want to be sensationalized less by a fabulist fantasy but by the spectacle of a slow-motion unraveling. This tension is by no means new, but it becomes particularly pronounced when the show tries to incorporate established figures who originate outside the franchise’s carefully controlled ecosystem. As a result, the franchise is caught between the competing impulses to preserve its legacy as a romantic ideal and to modernize itself for an audience that no longer believes in that mirage — resulting, most recently, in a casting that was doomed to fail on all fronts.
Taylor Frankie Paul, a woman whose claim to fame is predicated on her willingness to be unvarnished on camera, warts and all, came to prominence on Hulu phenomenon The Secret Lives of Mormon Wives, an overstimulating potpourri of high-octane, emotionally volatile sagas that feature everything from ketamine drips to swinger clubs. ABC’s attempt to metabolize Paul’s very public domestic troubles — documented since Season 1, Episode 1 of SLOMW — into something legible and brand-safe ultimately was a fiasco on all counts. Even at its most progressive, a program as choreographed as The Bachelor has limited capacity to embrace a lead who is actively unlearning the cycles of abuse; the franchise’s version of relatability, for better or worse, was built on sameness and predictability.
Part of that friction is structural, as the reality TV landscape undergoes its own contraction. According to industry data, unscripted entertainment is shrinking — a trend influenced in part by the decline of cable, the rise of creator-driven content, and the ongoing consolidation of media conglomerates — creating an increasingly precarious business that is reluctant to take risks even on its most established titles. It’s most evident with the recent wave of Housewives-affiliated pauses and cancellations on Bravo, but The Bachelorette’s recent stumble reinforces this pattern: The casting stunt backfired, resulting in a shelved season and executives scrambling to recalibrate.
But beyond the concerning realities of the industry, the Taylor Frankie Paul mess ultimately reveals not only a misalignment between a show and its audience, but a broader shift in how we understand