May 13, 2026 6:23am PT

‘Butterfly Jam’ Review: Barry Keoghan and Riley Keough Are Circassian Siblings in Kantemir Balagov’s Vibrant but Unruly Community Portrait

The 'Beanpole' director's third feature — and first in English — confirms his extraordinary formal and sensory capabilities, even when his script goes off-track.

Guy Lodge

Plus Icon

Guy Lodge

Film Critic

@guylodge

Latest

‘Is God Is’ Review: Aleshea Harris Makes Her Mark With a Brash, Blazing Female Revenge Thriller

2 days ago

‘The Python Hunt’ Review: An Entertainingly Garish Documentary Account of a State-Sanctioned Culling Spree

3 days ago

‘Remarkably Bright Creatures’ Review: Sally Field and Lewis Pullman Help Each Other Heal in a Melodrama of Distinctly Average Intelligence

6 days ago

See All

Why Not Productions

As earthly circles of hell go, modern-day Newark is in an altogether different, gentler category from post-WWII Leningrad. Still, in Kantemir Balagov‘s long-awaited third feature “Butterfly Jam,” industrial New Jersey proves as vivid and specific a backdrop for wilting, marginalized lives as the ruined Russian city did in the filmmaker’s 2019 masterpiece “Beanpole.” Though it’s the director’s first American-set work, he’s not as far from home as initially appears to be the case: A finely textured immigrant community study that engages meaningfully with his own Circassian heritage, “Butterfly Jam” is marked by unsentimental kinship with the rowdy, not-quite-settled expat family at its center, even with actors as unexpected as Barry Keoghan, Riley Keough and Harry Melling playing the parts.

'Butterfly Jam' Review: Barry Keoghan and Riley Keough Are Circassian Siblings in Kantemir Balagov's Vibrant but Unruly Community Portrait