Why no nation is truly ‘energy independent’ while the Strait of Hormuz remains closed

Marine traffic leaving the Middle East has again dropped from a trickle to barely a drip. This comes after a decision by the U.S. to blockade Iran’s ports in response to threats by Iran to attack energy exports it hadn’t approved leaving the critical Strait of Hormuz choke point.

Recommended Video

As Asia struggles with energy shortages that now threaten to spread to Europe, the U.S., meanwhile, remains bountifully supplied with almost record-high crude oil and natural gas production, leading President Donald Trump and others to tout the nation’s “energy independence.” Less than 3% of U.S. oil consumption typically comes from the Middle East—near an all-time low.

So why have gasoline, diesel, and jet fuel prices continued to spike? The U.S. average price for a gallon of regular unleaded gasoline is $4.11 as of April 15, according to AAA. That’s up 50% from a January low of $2.73. California, partially dependent on Asian fuel imports, spiked to $5.88 per gallon. For diesel, the national average is $5.64 a gallon.

“The problem is that oil is a global commodity. We may have plenty of oil—there’s no shortage of U.S. oil—but energy independence is somewhat of a fallacy,” said Jim Wicklund, veteran oil analyst and managing director at PPHB, an energy investment firm. “We still have to pay the going world price. It’s a global price.”

The U.S. may be much more “energy secure” than it was during the Arab oil embargoes of the 1970s, but it isn’t independent, Wicklund told Fortune. And the U.S. still imports a little more oil—largely from Canada, Mexico, and Venezuela—than it ships out.

The U.S. doesn’t have nearly enough surplus oil to fill the Middle Eastern void, Wicklund said, and U.S. oil drilling and production has ticked up only slightly since the war began.

There is growing talk of countries “hoarding oil” and restricting exports, said Arjun Murti, energy macro and policy partner at the Veriten research and investment firm. For the U.S., though, a hoarding strategy doesn’t appear that viable. That’s because the country must import heavier grades of crude oil for local refineries, and export excess lighter oil produced domestically, while U.S refineries need to export surplus gasoline and diesel or risk decreasing their operations.

“The instinct on politicians will be to restrict exports, but there’s the need to trade all of this stuff globally to match up supply and demand,” Murti told Fortune. “You can’t restrict your way to lower prices. You need the trade.”

The good news for the U.S. is that supply shortages almost certainly won’t occur because of its world-leading domestic production volumes. “The risk to us is inflation, and any hit to the global economy ultimately is a risk to our economy,” Murti said.

In the meantime, U.S. energy exports are on the rise, with combined crude oil and refined petroleum product exports hitting an all-time high of 12.7 million barrels a day for the week ended April 10. The exports spike is driven largely by the increasing drawdown of barrels from the U.S. Strategic Petroleum Reserve, which commenced in late March.

Benchmark oil prices are hovering above $90 per barrel—much higher than the roughly $60 price tag at the beginning of the year, but down since the ceasefire began on rising market optimism.

Still, it’s important to realize that the European and U.S. benchmarks, Brent and WTI, respectively, are futures contracts largely for oil trading. The front-month contract for Brent oil is for June barrels, while WTI—West Texas Intermediate—is still on the May contract until it settles April 21 and rolls over to June.

The barrels already set for physical delivery in the coming days and weeks, such as dated Brent, are selling for closer to $120—a historic gap between physical and futures prices.

“All these prices are linked globally. If prices go up somewhere, they go up everywhere,” Murti said.

Reaching a critical juncture

The growing problem is that—more than halfway through a two-week ceasefire in Iran—all the surplus oil and gas storage and waterborne shipments are running dry after a six-week-long supply shock.

“We’re getting to that critical point where higher flows of oil and refined products and other stuff—fertilizer and helium—are going to have to resume in greater quantities, or we run into the risk of a more severe hit to the global economy,” Murti said.

Wicklund said we’re less than two months from a “global recession” if the strait isn’t reopened before then. “I’m hopeful, but the situation has changed, and I think it’s gotten more dangerous,” Wicklund said, with the ceasefire being so tenuous and demands from both sides seemingly far apart.

By the end of May, the world enters into seasonal energy demand increases, including the busy summer driving season.

On April 15, the White House reiterated that it feels good about a potential deal. The leadership of the United Arab Emirates and Iran are talking, which could represent progress after Iran bo